Yes, the free license emails are marketing
Why I check other SQL clients' bug reports against SQLly, turn them into tests, and email the reporters a free lifetime license. Yes, it's self-promotion.
If you filed a bug against another SQL client lately, you may have gotten an email from me thanking you and handing you a free lifetime SQLly license. Yeah, that's marketing. Here's the whole story.
Someone called me out on it
I sent one of those emails to someone who'd reported a couple of issues against Sequel Ace. The reply came the next morning, and it didn't pull punches: this seemed a bit disingenuous. Why was I "thanking" them for reporting problems with a competitor's app? Seemed like I just wanted to point out that SQLly doesn't have that problem, and advertise my project. They didn't appreciate the approach.
And yeah, I get that. From a totally cynical point of view, they're right. I'm trying to get you to try SQLly. Maybe you like it, maybe you hate it. Either way, no big deal.
But the thanks was genuine, and since I'm going to keep doing this, I figured I'd explain it once, out loud, instead of one reply at a time.
What I actually do with your bug reports
There's a nearly endless supply of bug reports for other SQL clients. DBeaver, DataGrip, TablePlus, Beekeeper Studio, HeidiSQL, pgAdmin, Sequel Ace, Azure Data Studio, all of them have public trackers full of people carefully writing up what broke. If you're building one of these things, that's gold.
So every day I take a batch of those reports and check SQLly against each one. I use LLMs to do the grunt work of turning a report into an automated test, so I don't end up with the same problems. Then:
- If SQLly has the bug too, I fix it.
- If it doesn't, it usually gets a regression test anyway, so it can't sneak in later.
- If it's a feature request, I decide whether to build it. Sometimes that same day.
Every verdict goes in a ledger, and each batch gets written up in a competitor watch post that credits the people who filed the reports.
That middle number is the part that matters. Forty-three times, somebody else's bug report described a problem in my app too. Those people made SQLly better whether they meant to or not. The person who called me out? Their two reports gave me two more test cases. So, thanks for that.
Why give away licenses?
Because there's obviously some self-promotion involved, and I'm not going to pretend there isn't. I've spent a ridiculous amount of time building SQLly, and I'd like people to try it.
The normal way to do that is ads, sponsored posts, and a social feed full of growth-hacking bullshit. I don't want to do that, and you don't want to read it. Giving a lifetime license to someone whose bug report was actually useful seemed like a much better trade.
Is it guerrilla marketing? Sure. Does it feel a little spammy when it shows up in your inbox from someone you've never heard of? Probably. I get it. But who doesn't love free shit?
The rules I follow
- I only email people who put an address on their own public GitHub profile. I don't dig addresses out of commits or anywhere else.
- One email per person, no matter how many of your issues I checked. No follow-ups, no drip campaign, no mailing list.
- The email names your issue, links it, and says what I found when I checked SQLly against it.
- The license link works once and it's yours for good. Ignore it and nothing happens.
- Replies come straight to me. If you'd rather I hadn't written, tell me and I won't again.
SQLly has its issues too
"SQLly doesn't have that problem" is not the same as "SQLly doesn't have problems." It does. I recently shipped a scrolling fix that made typing lag, and had to turn around and fix that. There are bugs I know about and bugs I don't know about yet, and I'm working through them. The point of checking other people's reports isn't to dunk on anyone. It's to find my bugs before you do.
If you try SQLly and something's broken, tell me. Same deal as everyone else's bug reporters: write it up and it gets checked, fixed and tested.
Give it a try
SQLly is a native SQL client for macOS, Windows and Linux. You can download it here, and if you got one of my emails, the license is already yours. Good or bad, I want to hear what you think.
If you try it, great. If not, that's fine too. Either way, the thanks was genuine.